Fri Dec 31, 2004 1:21 am
ZEE QUESTIONS
1) What did you feel about a game of this size? Do you think there was too many people?
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones?
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched?
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
5) Length of the game... any comment on that?
6) If you have any role suggestions... please PM them to me.
7) If you have any general comments... post 'em here!
Look for signups in the coming week.
1) What did you feel about a game of this size? Do you think there was too many people?
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones?
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched?
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
5) Length of the game... any comment on that?
6) If you have any role suggestions... please PM them to me.
7) If you have any general comments... post 'em here!
Look for signups in the coming week.
Fri Dec 31, 2004 1:25 am
ZEE QUESTIONS
1) What did you feel about a game of this size? Do you think there was too many people?
A bit too many, but it was okay.
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones?
Good balance.
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched?
How about the deadies instead of soul stealing become like the president's role?
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
Interesting. I liked it.
5) Length of the game... any comment on that?
Really dragged on at the end. See above for my comment on soul stealing
6) If you have any role suggestions... please PM them to me.
Done.
7) If you have any general comments... post 'em here!
I like your post-requirements roles, like the Celeb and etc.
Look for signups in the coming week.
Wee, first fill out!
1) What did you feel about a game of this size? Do you think there was too many people?
A bit too many, but it was okay.
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones?
Good balance.
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched?
How about the deadies instead of soul stealing become like the president's role?
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
Interesting. I liked it.
5) Length of the game... any comment on that?
Really dragged on at the end. See above for my comment on soul stealing
6) If you have any role suggestions... please PM them to me.
Done.
7) If you have any general comments... post 'em here!
I like your post-requirements roles, like the Celeb and etc.
Look for signups in the coming week.
Wee, first fill out!
Fri Dec 31, 2004 1:28 am
1) I felt it was fine, but I would like to try 2 smaller games that will go faster. 
2)Yes, it seemed balance once again.
3) Keep it for at least another game, maybe we can fully utilize it then.
4) I was confused by the whole thing at first, but after reading over it a few times, I finally understood it. I can't really comment on it though, since I never got it.
5) It was long, but so was the last game. Not a problem for me.
6) I'd have to think about those for a while, I might send some to you though.
7) LONG LIVE THE INNOCENTS! *cough*
2)Yes, it seemed balance once again.
3) Keep it for at least another game, maybe we can fully utilize it then.
4) I was confused by the whole thing at first, but after reading over it a few times, I finally understood it. I can't really comment on it though, since I never got it.
5) It was long, but so was the last game. Not a problem for me.
6) I'd have to think about those for a while, I might send some to you though.
7) LONG LIVE THE INNOCENTS! *cough*
Fri Dec 31, 2004 1:31 am
ZEE QUESTIONS
1) What did you feel about a game of this size? Do you think there was too many people? Yes. God yes. For the first week or so I was so confused. x_x A cap at 30 for 2 separate games and then an intergrating of the two games together once they get down to low enough numbers sounds good to me. Like survivor!
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones? I honestly can't answer this since I wasn't in the game for that long. Although, I have to say sometimes it felt as though the bad guys outnumbered the good ones.
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched? It's a good idea but hard to execute as we saw. I'm not sure whether or not it should be ditched, that would right be up to you oh GM.
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of? Eh, it was pretty good.
5) Length of the game... any comment on that? It seemed to drag on forever. But, that could definately have something to do with the fact that I didn't feel attached to this game this time around.
*crawls up on Kugetsu's shoulders and waves a tiny "Go Innocents" flag*
1) What did you feel about a game of this size? Do you think there was too many people? Yes. God yes. For the first week or so I was so confused. x_x A cap at 30 for 2 separate games and then an intergrating of the two games together once they get down to low enough numbers sounds good to me. Like survivor!
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones? I honestly can't answer this since I wasn't in the game for that long. Although, I have to say sometimes it felt as though the bad guys outnumbered the good ones.
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched? It's a good idea but hard to execute as we saw. I'm not sure whether or not it should be ditched, that would right be up to you oh GM.
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of? Eh, it was pretty good.
5) Length of the game... any comment on that? It seemed to drag on forever. But, that could definately have something to do with the fact that I didn't feel attached to this game this time around.
*crawls up on Kugetsu's shoulders and waves a tiny "Go Innocents" flag*
Fri Dec 31, 2004 1:57 am
ScottNak wrote:ZEE QUESTIONS
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
It was easily taken advantage of.
Look for signups in the coming week.
Fri Dec 31, 2004 1:58 am
ScottNak wrote:ZEE QUESTIONS
1) What did you feel about a game of this size? Do you think there was too many people?
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones?
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched?
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
5) Length of the game... any comment on that?
6) If you have any role suggestions... please PM them to me.
7) If you have any general comments... post 'em here!
ZEE ANSWERS
1. I don't think there was too many people... of course, I'm used to large games. But I sorta did like the two smaller games integrating into one larger...
2. I think the balance was equaltized. Not too many innocents, not to many Baddies.
3. Sole stealing? I like the idea! As we saw, it was quite a useful ability.
4. I don't know. I've never gotten the Frozen Spirit, and I've never gotten the Jelly Blob. Errm... *Flips blue coin up in the air, it lands on heads* Keep it!
5. It was long. It would have gone faster, if it wasn't so close to Holidays, I think.
6. *Thinks*
7. Can I be on the innocents team next round, too? I don't want to break my all-innocent record for PPT... my Queen one on IDB was already brokeded.
... Of course being a Baddie is fun... so, go ahead and make it whatever you want. And stay away from those Poisoned Apples!
Fri Dec 31, 2004 2:26 am
1) What did you feel about a game of this size? Do you think there was too many people? Worked for me. Lots of things happend
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones?Well, since some roles can be ambiguous on wether they're good or bad, I'm not really a good person to ask.
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched? It's fun, but it's difficult rallying the deadies because usually, once you die, you're out of things to do.
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
Well, from wahta I could see, it was interesting, but if I was given it, I would have been to confused to figure it out.
5) Length of the game... any comment on that?
In my opinion, it was a bad idea to run it through the holidays. People go on vacations around this time, and have to leave
7)Lots of fun!
It's difficult to keep up with it if you miss a day though.
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones?Well, since some roles can be ambiguous on wether they're good or bad, I'm not really a good person to ask.
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched? It's fun, but it's difficult rallying the deadies because usually, once you die, you're out of things to do.
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
Well, from wahta I could see, it was interesting, but if I was given it, I would have been to confused to figure it out.
5) Length of the game... any comment on that?
In my opinion, it was a bad idea to run it through the holidays. People go on vacations around this time, and have to leave
7)Lots of fun!
It's difficult to keep up with it if you miss a day though.
Fri Dec 31, 2004 2:41 am
1) What did you feel about a game of this size? Do you think there was too many people?
DEAR GOD, YES.
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones?
I think that innocents winning the last four out of five games give you the idea there's an inbalance somewhere.
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched?
Ditch it.
Oh, come on, it lost me the game. I can't say I want it kept.
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
The thing that allows you to choose who dies? Keep it, I think.
5) Length of the game... any comment on that?
Next time don't give out so many execution avoiding powers. Things would have gone quicker without escapes.
7) If you have any general comments... post 'em here.
Poison jelly NEARLY pwned you.
DEAR GOD, YES.
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones?
I think that innocents winning the last four out of five games give you the idea there's an inbalance somewhere.
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched?
Ditch it.
Oh, come on, it lost me the game. I can't say I want it kept.
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
The thing that allows you to choose who dies? Keep it, I think.
5) Length of the game... any comment on that?
Next time don't give out so many execution avoiding powers. Things would have gone quicker without escapes.
7) If you have any general comments... post 'em here.
Poison jelly NEARLY pwned you.
Fri Dec 31, 2004 3:49 am
ZEE STUFF
1) What did you feel about a game of this size? Do you think there was too many people?
It's enough. I wasn't confused. I was okay....but I liked WW3 amount of people most...
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones?
Yup.
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched?
It's....mediocre.
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
O_o What's that? xDD
5) Length of the game... any comment on that?
No opinion.
7) If you have any general comments... post 'em here!
The end was confusing....not because I wasn't here for like 3 days....but because of Dawn. xD
What's the Jelly Blob?
Why no poem roles? xD
I liked my role...kinda.
And is it me or do I always get executed?
1) What did you feel about a game of this size? Do you think there was too many people?
It's enough. I wasn't confused. I was okay....but I liked WW3 amount of people most...
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones?
Yup.
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched?
It's....mediocre.
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
O_o What's that? xDD
5) Length of the game... any comment on that?
No opinion.
7) If you have any general comments... post 'em here!
The end was confusing....not because I wasn't here for like 3 days....but because of Dawn. xD
What's the Jelly Blob?
Why no poem roles? xD
I liked my role...kinda.
And is it me or do I always get executed?
Fri Dec 31, 2004 4:05 am
1) What did you feel about a game of this size? Do you think there was too many people?
I thought the size was perfect, as there were plenty of players to strategize with. Sure, it was confusing in the beginning but I think that it what sets the stage for the game.
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones?
I believe so.
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched?
I liked it, but maybe have less of a majority.
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
o_0
5) Length of the game... any comment on that?
Perfect length!
6) If you have any role suggestions... please PM them to me.
7) If you have any general comments... post 'em here!
I thought the size was perfect, as there were plenty of players to strategize with. Sure, it was confusing in the beginning but I think that it what sets the stage for the game.
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones?
I believe so.
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched?
I liked it, but maybe have less of a majority.
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
o_0
5) Length of the game... any comment on that?
Perfect length!
6) If you have any role suggestions... please PM them to me.
7) If you have any general comments... post 'em here!
Fri Dec 31, 2004 5:27 am
ScottNak wrote:ZEE QUESTIONS
1) What did you feel about a game of this size? Do you think there was too many people?
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones?
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched?
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
5) Length of the game... any comment on that?
7) If you have any general comments... post 'em here!
1) I liked the size, and thought it was the perfect amount of people.
2) I liked the roles! I think there could possibly be some different bad roles, but they were good!
3) I like the ideal, but it took alot of people to make it happen in the end.
4) Jelly Blob ROX!
5) I liked the length, and was almost sad to see it over...
7) It was fun, and gave me an excuse to not have to go shopping every day after school!
Fri Dec 31, 2004 6:30 am
1) What did you feel about a game of this size? Do you think there was too many people?
Way too many. Being new to the PPT forums I knew nobody by name really so it was hard to keep track of what everybody was talking about
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones?
More baddies...the innocents would have won a lot earlier if we had majorities faster
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched?
*cough* Lynch *cough*
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
Keep it but don't use it every game...maybe every 3 or something
5) Length of the game... any comment on that?
TOO LONG!!
6) If you have any role suggestions... please PM them to me.
I'll give em to NPM and you'll get em eventually
7) If you have any general comments... post 'em here!
You stole my Cheat Champion role!! *pulls out shotgun* Where are my royalties ??
Seriously though - since I don't come to these forums regularily I lost track of the thread quickly. Reading through about 25 pages to find yourself executed kinda sucks (Didn't check the front page )
Way too many. Being new to the PPT forums I knew nobody by name really so it was hard to keep track of what everybody was talking about
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones?
More baddies...the innocents would have won a lot earlier if we had majorities faster
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched?
*cough* Lynch *cough*
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
Keep it but don't use it every game...maybe every 3 or something
5) Length of the game... any comment on that?
TOO LONG!!
6) If you have any role suggestions... please PM them to me.
I'll give em to NPM and you'll get em eventually
7) If you have any general comments... post 'em here!
You stole my Cheat Champion role!! *pulls out shotgun* Where are my royalties ??
Seriously though - since I don't come to these forums regularily I lost track of the thread quickly. Reading through about 25 pages to find yourself executed kinda sucks
(Didn't check the front page )
Fri Dec 31, 2004 6:53 am
ScottNak wrote:ZEE QUESTIONS
1) What did you feel about a game of this size? Do you think there was too many people?
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones?
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched?
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
5) Length of the game... any comment on that?
6) If you have any role suggestions... please PM them to me.
7) If you have any general comments... post 'em here!
Look for signups in the coming week.
1) Yes... I was a bit confused. It should be capped at 35, IMO.
2) Yes, I think it was quite balanced. The innocents won only by a near margin.
3) Good, it helped the innocents win. I told you all it would be game-breaking and should be used wisely.
4) What is the jelly blob?
5) I think it was reasonable for the amount of players in it... though there were too many players IMO.
6) Already done.
7) I would like the next game to be set in somewhere more serious/forbidding, and with more scary baddies. Jelly world was a bit too light-hearted and the creepiness and suspense level was not high enough. *is a thrill junkie*
Fri Dec 31, 2004 7:07 am
1) What did you feel about a game of this size? Do you think there was too many people?
I think there were way too many. Capped at 35, I think.
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones?
Yep, I think so.
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched?
I like the idea, even though it was hard to get the right ammount of votes. >/
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
It was interesting. -eats jelly-
5) Length of the game... any comment on that?
Waaaaay too long. It drove me nutty, after I died. XD
6) If you have any role suggestions... please PM them to me.
7) If you have any general comments... post 'em here!
YAY WW6 YAY WW6
I think there were way too many. Capped at 35, I think.
2) How were the roles this game. Was there a fair balance of bad ones and good ones?
Yep, I think so.
3) What did you think about the whole SoulStealing idea? Is it good? Should it be ditched?
I like the idea, even though it was hard to get the right ammount of votes. >/
4) What about the Jelly Blob? Good? Get rid of?
It was interesting.
-eats jelly-
5) Length of the game... any comment on that?
Waaaaay too long. It drove me nutty, after I died. XD
6) If you have any role suggestions... please PM them to me.
7) If you have any general comments... post 'em here!
YAY WW6 YAY WW6
Fri Dec 31, 2004 7:09 am
Qanda - The jelly blob is the frozen spirit