Fantasia Barrino or Diana DeGarmo?

[Kitten Medli]

Yes,the battle continues..okay,not really. But I'd like to see if the runner up beats out the winner fanbase (on PPT) like lastyear. (Not saying they all arent great in their own ways,which they are.)

So,are you for Miss Smiley DeGarmo or the Bobo Barrino? My vote goes to Diana.



Fantasia Barrino
Winner



Diana DeGarmo
Runner Up

Dont know what they sound like?

Check here: http://www.idolexperience.com/finale.html

Last edited by Kitten Medli on Mon Jul 12, 2004 10:14 pm, edited 1 time in total.

[anti.]

Diana.

I never liked Donald Duck. Sorry.

[Kitten Medli]

Now,now,lets keep it nice..

You know,I didnt like Diana untill I heard her CD. If you go buy it,T.M.W.A.C.H.N,you wont regret it. Infact,you will be in pure shock. I was. Mom too.

EDIT: How'd you pull that? Your post is gone.

Last edited by Kitten Medli on Mon Jul 12, 2004 4:56 am, edited 1 time in total.

[T.M.W.A.C.H.N]

Now,now,lets keep it nice..

You know,I didnt like Diana untill I heard her CD. If you go buy it,T.M.W.A.C.H.N,you wont regret it. Infact,you will be in pure shock. I was. Mom too.

shock as in ow my ears hurt?

[Kitten Medli]

Now,now,lets keep it nice..

You know,I didnt like Diana untill I heard her CD. If you go buy it,T.M.W.A.C.H.N,you wont regret it. Infact,you will be in pure shock. I was. Mom too.

shock as in ow my ears hurt?

....



No,as in her voice is beautiful in a recording studio. She seemed weak,to me,live on TV and not very good..but when I heard her CD,my opinion changed greatly. Believe me. I had a grudge against her for a while. (She beat Huff daddy. )

[robot]

I didn't watch the show that often and the only reason I saw the finale was because my mother took over every television in the house.
I think they both had decent enough voices, but I wouldn't go out of my way to buy either of their albums.

[AmericanDamsel]

I watched AI a little bit last season and I didn't really like Fantasia. So I'll pick Diana DeGarmo her voice isn't annoying.

[coming2atvnearu]

Diana! Deffinly, Deffinly Diana.

Although, if John Stevens were an option...

[Kitten Medli]

Diana! Deffinly, Deffinly Diana.

Although, if John Stevens were an option...

Yeah,I know. Maybe I'll make another poll another time to see who the overall season three favorite is.

[shimmer]

I like Diana more. Fantasia sounds weird.

[Combusken BG]

I have no idea which one of two I think is better so if someone can give me a link for both of them singing then I will be able to say which one of them I think is better.

There should of been a Don't Know option.

[Bangel]

Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana.

Oh, yeah... and

Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana. Diana.

Listening to her version of 'I Believe' right now. She rocks. Sorry to say it, but Fantasia sounds a lot like a duck filled with helium. 'Nuff said. I'm working on getting tons of Diana sets- each one with one line from 'Dreams' on it. Then, I'll use them in order.

[coming2atvnearu]

Does anyone have the stats as to whos sold more?

I'd be very interested to see what's going on here and if they're gonna pull a Clay and Reuben

[Ammer]

Does anyone have the stats as to whos sold more?

I'd be very interested to see what's going on here and if they're gonna pull a Clay and Reuben

What happened between Clay and Ruben? Did they suddenly hate each other?

[Drake Redcrest]

I've never heard either of them, so neither.

Ammer, Ruben won but Clay sold more records. I think that's what coming2 is talking about.