Hilary Duff or Avril Lavigne?

[plushie]

post other opinions if you want, vote!

[Jen]

Y'know... It depends. Do you mean.. Singing... Acting.. Dancing... Personality... What.

If you mean singing and dancing... I can't comment, seeing as I can't sing or dance better than either, and I don't want to put myself down by saying that I worse than suck. Besides, how can you insult someone who's giving it their all and risking huge humiliation if they make a mistake, while you sit here on your butt and don't risk anything for any reason.

If you mean personality... I still can't really tell you seeing as I only really know what the media really wants me to, if they don't want you to know something, your not going to know it.

[plushie]

Y'know... It depends. Do you mean.. Singing... Acting.. Dancing... Personality... What.

If you mean singing and dancing... I can't comment, seeing as I can't sing or dance better than either, and I don't want to put myself down by saying that I worse than suck. Besides, how can you insult someone who's giving it their all and risking huge humiliation if they make a mistake, while you sit here on your butt and don't risk anything for any reason.

If you mean personality... I still can't really tell you seeing as I only really know what the media really wants me to, if they don't want you to know something, your not going to know it.

never thought of it that way *has really gotta think these things through* anything I guess. i just like avril better because hilary seems, well, strange IMO AND i like avrils music better

avril is REALLY weird looking without her makeup, bow down to whoever does her makeup xDD

[Igg]

Y'know... It depends. Do you mean.. Singing... Acting.. Dancing... Personality... What.

Any of them, I intensely dislike both.

[i_love_starburst]

Neither. Hate them. Please dispose of them. Quickly. >_<

[.:JAG:.]

They both suck....

I never want to hear of them again.

[floella_de_ville]

Avril Lavinge cos I like her music better.

[Silja]

Avril Lavigne, at least she can sing a bit.

[jellyoflight]

In my opinion, they both smell.


The only part of Avril I like is the song "Nobody's Home".

[Yoshi]

Avril Lavigne writes (though she needs co-writers, at least she still writes a little), Hilary doesn't. Hilary also needs her recorded tracks played over her voice in concerts. That being said...Avril, although I also don't like her that much.

[DM was on fire!]

Gah, I feel like such a loner. I voted for Hilary Duff. She's a really funny actor and I love most of her songs. The only Avril song I like is Nobody's Home.

[Sock]

Avril Lavigne writes (though she needs co-writers, at least she still writes a little), Hilary doesn't. Hilary also needs her recorded tracks played over her voice in concerts. That being said...Avril, although I also don't like her that much.

I'd have to agree.

A year ago or so, I had a DVD of Avril singing live...well, from what I saw she can't sing all that well live. But her CDs are fine and dandy to listen to, although I won't be putting her on my top ten list anytime soon.

[happysmileyfungirl]

I voted Avril, Hillary's acting and singing irritate me and I don't mind Avril Lavigne that much.

[Kitten Medli]

I dislike both of them, but I don't hate them at all and they do not suck. However, I do like Breakaway, which Avril wrote.. besides that.. no.

[Rikku]

Neither. I dislike both of them.