Harry Potter Facedown, Round 15 (spoilers, duh)

[Tharkun]

Looking through the archives to compile statistics, I found that Dumbledore won the competitions five times. He lost fair and square to Sirius his sixth time, but he still qualifies for the Hall of Fame. Good.

All right, McGonagall trounces Fudge with 97% of the votes. Yeowza. I don't think it'll get any more decisive than that.

She goes on to face:

From OotP:

McGonagall

vs.

Phineas Nigellus


Phineas Nigellus, as I am a fan of obscure fics, is someone I would dearly love to see fics about. Especially considering my Sirius obsession. But remembering McGonagall in the Headmaster's office, that all goes out the window.

(Corrected for grammar. Pleh.)

Last edited by Tharkun on Sat Aug 20, 2005 8:18 am, edited 1 time in total.

[Divine]

This is a lot more harder than last time. Hehe...

Anyways, while Phineas Nigellus is a funny character, I can't say I exactly liked him that much.

Remembering some of McGonagall's famous quotes, like the cough drop, the chandelier, and how she flares her nostrils, she's better than Phineas any day =D.

[Jamie]

No-one can beat McGonagall for me. Except perhaps Dobby. Dobby rocks. Another vote for McGonagall again from me this week.

[Alex]

McGonagall.

Waaaay too many hilarious quotes to ignore.

[Flame]

McGonagall. Phineus was amusing at times, but he has nothing on McGonagall.

[Monique]

McGonagall, even if voting for her is getting a little old. I dunno, she's just beginning to seem a little over-rated to me. Like think about all the times she pushes things aside thinking it's nothing, when in reality it causes a lot of problems later(mainly referring to book 1 and 6)

[monsum01]

McGonagall would kick Phin all the way.....

[vkceankraz]

McGonagall, definitely -- she's just ridiculously awesome and sardonic. I loved her in OotP when she "nicely" told off Umbridge.

[Matterbug]

I love you McGonagall...

[AFI_Sorrow]

Once again voting and showing the love for McGonagall.