Harry Potter Facedown, Round 17 (spoilers, duh) (lockable)

[Tharkun]

Well, Snape loses by quite the sizeable margin, but Lupin is a pretty popular character, so that proves nothing.

Anyway.

From HBP:

Lupin

vs.

Scrimgeour


Not only is it a big "no contest" on a character standpoint, but I also resent that JKR sank into bald-faced political allegory.

Last edited by Tharkun on Sat Oct 01, 2005 12:43 am, edited 1 time in total.

[Flame]

Lupin. Duh. ^^;; Scrimgeour could've been a much more interesting character I think, but...he wasn't.

[Divine]

I agree with Flame fully. Besides, JKR wrote about Scrimgeour in such a negative way, I realllyyy doubt that people actually like him.

[Monique]

I like Lupin a lot better than him, so my vote is pretty obvious.

[Sakura]

Lupin is amazing. Truthfully his impression in HBP was kind of lacking, but I love him nonetheless.

[Amethyst]

Lupin rocks! And Scrimgeour was a bit of a let down with that whole description thing....

[.:Requiem:.]

Much as I dislike Lupin, I have to go with him again. Scrimgeour is one of the worst character's she's ever come up eith. Bloody Fudge-clone..

[VeraX]

Lupin, he's so dang cool.

[monsum01]

Well for some reason I believe in Lupin.... he just seems a little better to me...

[archergirl2000]

Lupin for sure, he's just more likeable then Scrimgeour , and plus I'm still mad at the dear newly enstated m.o.m treating Harry so badly

[Forest_Majesty]

I love Lupin
Scrim is just... blah, at first he seemed great and then treating Harry so meanly made me mad

[Kuri]

Lupin! Scrimgeour just...disappointed me as a character. He just...was... he didn't seem like a person to me, just a random character.

[Alex]

Lupin.

Easily.