In the blue one I think the menu should all be either aligned towards the left or the right...I don't like the way it seems centered. I also don't fancy the empty buttons across the top of the menu, where it says "home" etc. I think we should either fill them or take them out. I also think the little font is a little too small and not functional when trying to surf. I'm wearing my contacts and still have trouble deciphering it, well not completely but yeah. I sort of like how the google adverts on this one are on the left, not in the mddle top like the yellow one because it makes them less conspicous, I actually had to search for them.
The yellow one to me seems more flashy, might call attention more which is a good thing to bring in members or attract their attention. I don't know if I like the size of the big red buttons but they are okay. I agree with Hunter about the links not fitting in the menu bar properly, that's got to get fixed because if not it just looks really tacky. Not sure I like the yellow used for the background color in the this one.
I'm still undecided as of which I like best, I'll get to you on that later

. If we could combine these things and fix the bad things and use all the good things, we'd have a super layout with which we could rule the world!!!!
