Pink Poogle Toy Forum

I'd probably say the first movie. It was the first introduction to Harry Potter and his friends. Everything was new. I'm a sucker for nostalgia.

Three diffently. It might be different to the book one in many parts, but I like it the best.

i havent seen hp 3 so hp 2 is good

Agreed, except I'm not sorry.

Overall, the look of the whole thing was better in the third one. I just enjoyed the ways scenes faded into one another instead of the screen blacking out for a nanosecond or what not. It meshed better.

And the story was just cooler than the other two, so that makes it a lot more biased.

I pick 2/3 because i know 3 is going to be best but i dont have 3 yet so 2/3

the 3rd one is so cool, im glad its winning 9 out of 13

They will probably do two movies for the 4th and 5th, that way the 6th book might be out in time so they can make a movie each year.

i gotta say harry potter 3 is pretty cool

I think the first one is best- because they're all so young and cute! ^-^

I gotta say that the third movie was the best! I love the third book and its story! Then its 4, then 1, then 5, then 2. I don't like the second book at all and I didn't like the movie either! XP

It depends on what you're talking about.

If it's 'most faithful to canon', PS/SS.

Best characterization? PS/SS.

Capturing the essence of the books? PoA.

I did hate PoA. The second half. The rest was brilliant, even if it wasn't faithful, and even if Kloves has yet again made Ron a blubbering buffoon and comic relief. And the only reason I hated the second half was because of Mary Sue!Hermione. I mean, looking at that half of the movie, they might as well have called the film 'Hermione 'Mary Sue' Granger and the Prisoner of Azkaban'.

Enough of a 'Purist's rantings.

PoA did get the feeling and tone of the book right, unlike the first two films. In that essence, it was the best movie. But then I remember the 'other half', and I remember how Hermione was Hermione and Ron was Ron in the first film, and not 'Hermione-Sue' and 'Buffoon Ron, the comic relief'.

On the other hand, Hermione was a bit of a 'Sue in PS/SS (the movie), with the Devil's Snare, and all. Oh well.

And on the other other hand, I was veeerrry happy with the amounts of R/Hr in PoA.

Even if they didn't like each other in that way, at the time.

I'll still go with PS/SS, though.

(And movie four is not going to be in two parts- before he left HP, Cuaron talked Newell into making it as one movie, with no intermissions (I think), or anything. Which was stupid, in my opinion, as now we've found out that they're cutting the Dursley's, and probably cutting the Quidditch World Cup, too. >:O)

Definitely POA! It was brillant! It might not have been as true to the books, and been a litte rushed, but I think it had more of JK's feeling of the HP world in it. It was more detailed and seemed more.. I dunno fantasy.

And not to mention Emma Watson was hot in this movie!

All of them are great...but the latest was the best!!!