Werewolf Commentary Excess (Nov. 20-30)

[gundam_kola01]

I have a few people in mind. I'm sure there's some baddies in this list.

1. Dawn2
2. Ixistant
3. Puk102701
4. Matt
5. Yesitish

Give me one good reason why my name is on that list, rather than that I voted for you.

I find you all suspicious the moment most of you all voted against me.
So now it's up to the others to speculate.

To gundam in the commentary thread: that thread is for non-playing people, too...

I know it's an opinion. I'm just pointing out that what you said isn't necessarily what might happen/be true in the game.

No, I'm not a player. However, I do enjoy following the game and contributing to the commentary discussion. Werewolf is fun for everyone, not just the people who signed up for that particular game. =)

Sorry, if i sounded rude. ^^"
I still learning as a newbie in this game. However, I played a similiar game before in real life.
So my opinions are based on my experience & observations...

Edit:

1. Kugetsu is not a she.
2. He was just saying that when there's a lot of baddies, they end up killing one of their own.
3. You don't lose your role - if Gundam told us of his role, the angel/shaman/whatnot could have protected her.
I'm not defending Kugetsu, just stating facts.

How can u bully a newbie...
I shall vote u back.
Vote: Dawn2

Dawn2 said:
Excuse me, but I'm not "bullying". Everyone has to guess on the first execution, and you were my random pick. It's likely that you won't be executed because of one vote, so please don't take it personally.

gundam_kola01 said:
Oh really? If u drop the idea of me being the baddie, I shall vote somebody else instead u then.

I did hinted to you all... But you all got the wrong idea...
Btw, I'm a she not a he.


JasEdit: Please do not double post. If you were the last person to post and you want to add more, please use the "edit" button in the top right of each of your posts.

[Xandra]

I don't really suspect Dawn- she did start the majority vote, but... Eh. I dunno. Just seems innocent to me. oO

Sorry, if i sounded rude. ^^"
I still learning as a newbie in this game. However, I played a similiar game before in real life.
So my opinions are based on my experience & observations...

It's quite alright. Just a misunderstanding, that's all. =)

[gundam_kola01]

Hahahas...

My Opinion again!

Innocence... Hmmm... Another possible way to distract the others. Soon or later, people will start to suspect you.


*************************************************************

Gundam, why am I on the list. Is it because I argued that we should try for an execution on the first day or because I pointed out that your posts were suspicious, or your awful grammar and spelling? Also,

Oh really? If u drop the idea of me being the baddie, I shall vote somebody else instead u then.

How is that hinting. Thats saying "I will unvote you if you unvote me", not "I am a cherub, don't execute me".

Ah huh!:D Am i sensing something... Or fishy now...
Now i'm suspecting you. Why're you so worked up?

When somebody pinpointed me, i also felt worked up. You should know how i felt that time. Becoz of your worked up behaviour, therefore make others think that you're the baddie. Normal human reaction.

For my grammar, pardon me. Becoz of I was so agitated that time, therefore wat i wrote maybe doesn't sound rite.

[AutumnElf]

Noo! I was actually killed the first round ._.

I've always lived to the end on the other ones...

And don't ask me why I chose evil.

But since I'm dead, I'll help the innocents...I guess.

A few people I think may be evil are on this list: (In no particular order)

1. Ixistant
2. Kugetsu
3. Matt
4. Urthdigger
5. Wind

No particular reason, you could call it gut instinct.

[Ammer]

Aw, that sucks. I can't get far in these games. Oh well.

Yes, I have a sibling. Obviously I'm good. Put two and two together.

I really have no suspects aside from White_Wolf who seemed really determined to kill Xil this game. Perhaps she was the theif. However, I don't think she would set herself up like that.

Anywho, I'm off to bed.

[warxelo]

Gah!! I liked my role too.... :( To be honest as soon as i stole this "person's" role, I had a feeling that s/he would be targeted because there was no death by maul or shoot last night.. when the game is over or when this person dies then youd know why i thought that.

[Puck102701]

Uh, I was the physcologist, as you probably already know. And I didn't get to have an appointment with anyone!

[Xandra]

Ouch. This night didn't help the innocents at all. x_x

Archangel and Psychologist gone... Not good.

My number one suspect is FlatLuigi. Why? To me, it seems as if he's trying too hard to fit in with the innocents.

It's a good strategy for villains to think and act like the townspeople/innocents. But it usually backfires, as it's difficult to completely change from villain to innocent when posting on the game thread, then go back to plotting over AIM/with yourself.

[okamotosan18]

Darn, I was hoping I'd make it at least half way through the game after I was converted. Oh well, darn shame. To the Cult, and other bad guy teams, you should probably try to kill the govenor because that person has a lot more power in this game since this is the first game where you have to get a majority of all living players instead of all voting players.
Anyway, I'm glad I didn't have to lie. When I said I was innocent, I was, haha

[gundam_kola01]

So many people died! Omg our archangel died! Seems to me that the bad guy will win in this round of game?

Oh well, who knows tables will turn.
I think now we have to suspect those who are inactive now.

Here the list of surviors left:

_jaye_
Alisquid
Dawn2
DM was on fire!
flatluigi
Ixistant
jellyoflight
Kidwaiy
Kugetsu
Lass
luckystar101
Matt
meowth1982
Nelly
Nikita
o_0
Puppylover
Raze
Shadowfare
Squinchy
ste_is_back
Stephanie
Twinkle
Twizzler0171
Urthdigger
Wind
YesItIsh

Last edited by gundam_kola01 on Wed Nov 24, 2004 2:44 pm, edited 1 time in total.

[Alex]

My number one suspect is FlatLuigi. Why? To me, it seems as if he's trying too hard to fit in with the innocents.

It's a good strategy for villains to think and act like the townspeople/innocents. But it usually backfires, as it's difficult to completely change from villain to innocent when posting on the game thread, then go back to plotting over AIM/with yourself.

I'm also suspecting him. Half gut instinct, half him trying to 'fit in' - yes, I know it's your first game. But it seems you're trying too hard, so you can try and fly under the radar. I dunno, there's just something that screams "omg fishy behaviour!"

Alex, it doesn't always backfire We were a great team.. until the Mafia killed me.. and you killed yourself

[Qanda]

Missed signups. This game does seem to be more complicated though, let's see how the you all fare this time round.

[Xandra]

Flatluigi: I suspect you because, as I said, it seems as if you're trying too hard to fit in. My point is, if you're an innocent, you don't need to fit in. =P

My number one suspect is FlatLuigi. Why? To me, it seems as if he's trying too hard to fit in with the innocents.

It's a good strategy for villains to think and act like the townspeople/innocents. But it usually backfires, as it's difficult to completely change from villain to innocent when posting on the game thread, then go back to plotting over AIM/with yourself.

I'm also suspecting him. Half gut instinct, half him trying to 'fit in' - yes, I know it's your first game. But it seems you're trying too hard, so you can try and fly under the radar. I dunno, there's just something that screams "omg fishy behaviour!"

Alex, it doesn't always backfire We were a great team.. until the Mafia killed me.. and you killed yourself

True. >=3 But as I said. Usually it does. We were semi-lucky, as none of the innocents really suspected you, Emma or I. =D

[Ammer]

I don't think flatluigi is that suspicious as Twinkle, Shadowfare, Jelly and DM was on fire! are.

Twinkle hasn't posted yet as far as I know but whilst the voting, she kept trying to make me look like a baddie. Most likely trying to kill me to draw attention away from her if any fell on her. I just don't have a good vibe about her.

Shadowfare made no remorse what so ever (Or none that I saw) saying anything about "Aw, we lost good people". She just went on in the game. It makes me think that she was happy we lost innocents because maybe she isn't one.

Jelly is one of the suspects. I'm not sure if Chris convinced her that I was bad because I don't know what she is saying about him lying. I know he was lying about being good so that might be it. But she seemed to eager to kill me.

DM was on fire! is my newest one because she seems to go right to the next person who was suspected during my 'life'. It was a decision between Kugetsu and I and people chose me. And because I turned out innocent she is starting to suspect Kugetsu. Don't get me wrong, she could be right but I don't like how she just went to the second person who was suspicious. It's a little odd.

However, out of all four, I think Shadowfare should be executed.

[DM was on fire!]

If you are alive in the game thread - You are not allowed to post here. If you want to talk about someone's post here, talk about it in the main thread. People can still see it, remember.

I won't take it any further, but I'll have to consult with Scott

~ Matt

EDIT - I'm sorry Matt. I didn't know.