Werewolf at Doom Castle Excess [Sat. 14 May - Tue. 17 May]

[Qanda]

Edit: I thought we could post our SPs when they are used up.

You may describe what it is, but you cannot quote/copy and paste my PM wholesale.

For example, you may say that "I had an SP which allowed me to escape executions by posting two smilies", but you cannot quote my exact PM to you.

Last edited by Qanda on Tue May 17, 2005 2:17 pm, edited 1 time in total.

[CWisgood]

Oops... sorry...

These rules are a bit weird. What's the difference between quoting and describing it?

[o_0]

Donag, Eber, Peleg, Reu, Eber, Calam, Arbit, Teelay, Eber.

Vote: Sirclucky

I'm trusting you on this one.

[Qanda]

Day 3 votes:

sirclucky - 2: CWisgood, o_0

21 alive, 11 votes for majority, 16 for locking

[sirclucky]

Vote: CWisgood

I told CWisgood that I was the protector. Then what does he do? tryings to say a "day dream" pointed to me being evil. First off, why didnt your "source" simply come out in public and state it themselves. You were already suspect by everyone else, you are the last person id think they would trust you with the information. You can kill me and get rid of a protector - or kill cw and get rid of a possible baddie.

[Wind]

So you're saying the dreamer himself must come out and announce the results of his dream? Seems a bit suicidal to me
I admit CWisgood is kinda suspicious, but I'm going to trust him.
Vote: Sirclucky

[maniac]

Eh, sorry I've been a bit busy... can someone give me a summary of what has been happening please??

[Wind]

Yesterday The Applehat accused CWisgood, because he said he revealed him his role.
He said CWisgood killed him.
So we voted for CWisgood, but he activated a SP and didn't get executed.
Blk Mage died, he could double or stop someone's power he was innocent.
Now CWisgood says a dreamer told him Sirclucky is evil.

[Qanda]

Day 3 votes:

sirclucky - 3: CWisgood, o_0, Wind
CWisgood - 1: sirclucky

21 alive, 11 votes for majority, 16 for locking

[sirclucky]

What im saying is that the dreamer would have had to be stupid to trust CW, the most suspected person at the time, with the fact that he was a dreamer. If the "day dream" was instead of secret power given to a random person, it would be much more advantageous for him/her to publically share the news and thus clear their name. Either way, simply sharing it with CW makes no sence at all.

[Kalathalan]

I just caught up on reading, and what an argument this is turning out to be.

I am now 99% convinced that CWisgood lives up to his name, because of the title of his SP - Angelic Defence. I would assume a baddie would not have an SP entitled "Angelic Defence", more like "Demonic Defence", or something of the sort. After all, a baddie is evil, right?

Also, it appears as if CWisgood copied the contents of his SP in its exact, unaltered form, because of the way Qanda worded his statements about CWisgood's rule violation.

So, I am now 99% convinced that CWisgood is, well, good

So, without further ado, I place my vote -- Vote: Sirclucky -- unless further evidence proves otherwise.

[sirclucky]

Secret powers are randomly assinged. The title of the SP has nothing to do with the persons role. If it did, Qanda would have MKed him.

One day CW is the top suspect, the enxt day you are trusting him? I simply dont follow the reasonig behind that.

[Wind]

What im saying is that the dreamer would have had to be stupid to trust CW, the most suspected person at the time, with the fact that he was a dreamer.

Well, did you consider the possibility that the dreamer contacted CWisgood after he dreamt of him?

[sirclucky]

In almost any game ive played, there hasnt been a dreamer that can dream of "good or evil". Normally dreamers get to dream about a single bad role about a player. If they can totally clear players, that allows alliance building which totally offsets the allingment of the game.

[Kalathalan]

Unvote: sirclucky

The random assignment of the SP is true, I forgot about that.

Let's see where this goes, then I'll place my vote.