WW17: The Return [GamePlay]

Message

Matterbug · #91 Post by **Matterbug** » Mon Jun 12, 2006 7:37 pm

Hopefully werewolves don't like to eat unicorns.

#92 Post by **theonlysaneone** » Mon Jun 12, 2006 7:39 pm

They might like to eat unicorns... until they meet a couple of my pet Flaming Rainbow Unicorns.

ScottNak · #93 Post by **ScottNak** » Mon Jun 12, 2006 7:42 pm

Anoohilator: Voting for nobody as your last vote, invalidates your vote on Xela (contradictory votes).

No Execution (14): Ziggy, Bangel, kidwaiy, DM was on fire!, Dyl, Xela of Xandra, Ixistant, Twizzler0171, Chipper, YesItIsh, Divine, WIS, Pixa, Anoohilator

TDG (2): Kugetsu, Christopher,
Christopher (2): TDG, CWisgood

theonlysaneone (1): Jamie
Jamie (1): theonlysaneone,
DM was on fire! (1): Blk Mage
Blk Mage (1): Kugetsu
endeavourl (1): matterbug
Kugetsu (1): Wind
Pixa (1): endeavourl
CWisgood (1): Christopher

Xandra · #94 Post by **Xandra** » Mon Jun 12, 2006 7:49 pm

theonlysaneone wrote:They might like to eat unicorns... until they meet a couple of my pet Flaming Rainbow Unicorns.

How many pet Flaming Rainbow Unicorns do you have?

Anoohilator · #95 Post by **Anoohilator** » Mon Jun 12, 2006 7:56 pm

ScottNak wrote:Anoohilator: Voting for nobody as your last vote, invalidates your vote on Xela (contradictory votes).

Yup did it on purpose

Kidwaiy · #96 Post by **Kidwaiy** » Mon Jun 12, 2006 8:04 pm

Well I guess No Execution wins.

Ziggy · #97 Post by **Ziggy** » Mon Jun 12, 2006 8:26 pm

Indeed. I'm a bit nervous about the first night, but we'll know soon enough. I agree with Scott - random killings are not cool, you could take out someone with a good role.

#98 Post by **theonlysaneone** » Mon Jun 12, 2006 8:28 pm

Xela of Xandra wrote:
theonlysaneone wrote:They might like to eat unicorns... until they meet a couple of my pet Flaming Rainbow Unicorns.

How many pet Flaming Rainbow Unicorns do you have?

If I told you, you'd use that knowledge to your advantage. However, I can say they're in the double-digits.

Xandra · #99 Post by **Xandra** » Mon Jun 12, 2006 8:41 pm

theonlysaneone wrote:
Xela of Xandra wrote:
theonlysaneone wrote:They might like to eat unicorns... until they meet a couple of my pet Flaming Rainbow Unicorns.

How many pet Flaming Rainbow Unicorns do you have?

If I told you, you'd use that knowledge to your advantage. However, I can say they're in the double-digits.

Well, just by saying THAT I know what it probably is! A NUMBER!

omg.

Matterbug · #100 Post by **Matterbug** » Mon Jun 12, 2006 9:16 pm

Xela of Xandra wrote:
theonlysaneone wrote:
Xela of Xandra wrote:
theonlysaneone wrote:They might like to eat unicorns... until they meet a couple of my pet Flaming Rainbow Unicorns.

How many pet Flaming Rainbow Unicorns do you have?

If I told you, you'd use that knowledge to your advantage. However, I can say they're in the double-digits.

Well, just by saying THAT I know what it probably is! A NUMBER!

omg.

OH NOES.

*dies*

Xandra · #101 Post by **Xandra** » Mon Jun 12, 2006 9:21 pm

matterbug wrote:
Xela of Xandra wrote:
theonlysaneone wrote:
Xela of Xandra wrote:
theonlysaneone wrote:They might like to eat unicorns... until they meet a couple of my pet Flaming Rainbow Unicorns.

How many pet Flaming Rainbow Unicorns do you have?

If I told you, you'd use that knowledge to your advantage. However, I can say they're in the double-digits.

Well, just by saying THAT I know what it probably is! A NUMBER!

omg.

OH NOES.

*dies*

woah, wait, why did you die?! =O

Matterbug · #102 Post by **Matterbug** » Mon Jun 12, 2006 9:23 pm

woah, wait, why did you die?! =O

I already told you my feelings on numbers.

Kugetsu · #103 Post by **Kugetsu** » Mon Jun 12, 2006 9:49 pm

Ziggy wrote:Indeed. I'm a bit nervous about the first night, but we'll know soon enough. I agree with Scott - random killings are not cool, you could take out someone with a good role.

The problem is, the same thing is going to happen the next night (making it even worse for the innocents), and the night after that, with the chance of hitting an innocent either slightly decreasing by the more innocents killed, or it GREATLY increasing with the more baddies that are killed, so if baddies die tonight, or a baddie and some innocents, then we're going to be in the exactly same spot as we would be at the beginning of the game, which, in retrospect, makes it pointless to even have a no execution unless late in the game when innocents have the upper hand (which they don't right now, as it's an even battleground).

I've gone on about this a million times and have found nothing useful about delaying what our job as innocents are, unless there is some tactical advantage, which there is not here.

Also, if a person votes no execution on day one, and is actually against executions on day one, would it not also be hypocritical to vote for anyone on day two or three (unless, as I said, a dream comes along, or a role reveal)?

Edit - Also, Scott didn't say random voting was bad, he said that voting for things that are not in the game is.

Anoohilator · #104 Post by **Anoohilator** » Mon Jun 12, 2006 10:01 pm

Kugetsu wrote:
Ziggy wrote:Indeed. I'm a bit nervous about the first night, but we'll know soon enough. I agree with Scott - random killings are not cool, you could take out someone with a good role.

The problem is, the same thing is going to happen the next night (making it even worse for the innocents), and the night after that, with the chance of hitting an innocent either slightly decreasing by the more innocents killed, or it GREATLY increasing with the more baddies that are killed, so if baddies die tonight, or a baddie and some innocents, then we're going to be in the exactly same spot as we would be at the beginning of the game, which, in retrospect, makes it pointless to even have a no execution unless late in the game when innocents have the upper hand (which they don't right now, as it's an even battleground).

I've gone on about this a million times and have found nothing useful about delaying what our job as innocents are, unless there is some tactical advantage, which there is not here.

Also, if a person votes no execution on day one, and is actually against executions on day one, would it not also be hypocritical to vote for anyone on day two or three (unless, as I said, a dream comes along, or a role reveal)?

Edit - Also, Scott didn't say random voting was bad, he said that voting for things that are not in the game is.

But the most horriblest feeling ever is being killed first day when you didn't deserve it. Reminds me of everyone killing Simon in LotF...

Bangel · #105 Post by **Bangel** » Mon Jun 12, 2006 10:18 pm

Anoohilator wrote:Reminds me of everyone killing Simon in LotF...

That was so sad. :( It was worse when Piggy died, though.