Pink Poogle Toy Forum

Recap

House won against Star Trek (what?!). So it is now in the Hall of Fame because it's getting boring, and... yeah. Fresh new competitors this week. Hurrah.

***

Week Eleven
Lost VS. American Idol

***

Previous Competitors
Desperate Housewives (Lost Week 7 to House, M.D.)
Grey's Anatomy (Lost Week 1 to Futurama)
House, M.D. (Won Week 6-10; Added to Hall of Fame)
Family Guy (Lost Week 3 to The Simpsons)
Friends (Lost Week 4 to The Simpsons)
Futurama (Won Week 1, lost to The Simpsons in Week 2)
M*A*S*H (Lost Week 5 to The Simpsons)
Simpsons, The (Won Weeks 2-5; lost to House, M.D.)
Star Trek (Lost Week 10 to House, M.D.)
Survivor (Lost Week 8 to House, M.D.)
Veronica Mars (Lost Week 9 to House, M.D.)

***

Hall of Fame
House, M.D. (Won Weeks 6-10)

***

Coming Soon
Doctor Who
Firefly
Bleach

Suggestions are greatly appreciated. Any television show is open for suggestion, whether it's a reality show, a soap opera, or a cartoon; still filming, or cancelled years ago.

*gonk*
Never watched Lost, getting freaking tired of American Idol. So...neither.
Is Dog the Bounty Hunter gonna be on soon? *doesn't care if she's the only one who votes for it*

American Idol for me. I need one mindless TV show to watch, and Lost requires too much thinking for me usually and I just can't get into it.

Lost all the way!

I'm split. D:

Lost is a great show for all intents and purposes, but sometimes I find myself forgetting that it's going to be on whenit's scheduled.

American Idol however, doesn't have as rampant repeats as Lost and I actually HAVE to watch it when it's on to keep up with it, since I most likely won't see it after it's aired the first time.

Eww. D: I'm going to have to go with Lost, because it required a lot more thinking and work to set up. I suppose, in the end, American Idol is basically just a basic singing competition, while Lost is unlike pretty much any other show.

The only show I watch on Wednesday or one of the ones I avoid like the plague. The plague with HIV, SARS and bird flu mixed with a touch of ebola.

Vote Lost for the next Hall of Fame spot!

American Idol FTW. I never got into Lost.

Lost

In my honest opinion an American drama television series that follows the present and past lives of a group of plane crash survivors on a mysterious tropical island is much more interesting than a reality show where we have to put up with awful singers who are trying to make it in the music business.

*Combusken BG wonders if Lost will vote Lost*

Lost, never got into AI.

Lost. I haven't watched it in a while but it's entertaining...American Idol is just boring and annoying.

American Idol. I don't like it much but im a singer so ..yeah..

I for a fact detest lost. I can't stand it.

I don't like either of them, but I'm voting for Lost because at least it's not stupid, annoying, or that boring. American Idol is all of those.

Suggestions: Mythbusters and Heroes

It would be interesting if it was Lost vs. Heroes since they share a producer or two and they have the same amount of suspense, speculation, and something that ties everything in together (the numbers for Lost and the RNA strand for Heroes)

Lost! Kill all Idol shows!

LOST! AI was interesting for the very first season, then I got bored with it. Lost gives me adrenalin highs everytime I watch it (every time major characters die or giant huge things happen, you can often find me in chat unable to type properly, repeating "OMG.OMG.OMG.OMG." for hours on end), so it automatically trumps AI anyway.

LOST LOST LOST LOST LOST

I'm just so happy it finally got in here

I can't watch American Idol, except for the beginning auditions. There's about 5 minutes of real TV in each episode. I just can't take it.