WW36: Battle for Middle-Earth Game Thread - GAME OVER

[Katherine]

Treebeard! No! My favourite character is already dead

[Bruces galore]

Poor pardona, died early two games in a row. I liked Treebeard in the books too. There's no way I can see Treebeard being evil. Must have been either a neutral or innocent role.
Vote: Christopher
because he voted for me last round
Location: the shire

Edit: In response to pardona over in dead land. If you aren't res banned, which it appears you aren't from the player list, there is a chance someone could res you at any point throughout the game. So keep following the game and see what happens.

[Ammer]

Vote: DM was on fire!
Vote: loser1921

No reason, just random!

[Pink]

garg...sorry for not being around yesterday...my hubby and I are in the process of moving and I was out and about all day...literally...didn't get home until midnight. Anyway.

Vote: Wind (totally random)
Movement: Rivendell

[May]

Hmm, both Twizz and Christopher have interesting theories. Christopher's theory makes sense if you follow the actual story line of the books, where Sauron is dead at the beginning of the book. Twizz's idea is just really neat from a host's point of view.

Let's see what we have for attacks:

Night 1:

Oliphants - Attack (Men from the South?)
Lava - Attack (Sauron's)
Whip of fire - Attack (Balrog from Moria?)
Tipsy - Disabling role usage
Terrified - Disabling SP usage

Night 2:

Ball of fire - Attack
Large creature - Attack
Tipsy - Disabling role usage
Terrified - Disabling SP usage

I'm wondering if the "large creature" from Night 2 was another Oliphant or something different. And would the ball of fire be from the same person who produced the whip of fire on Night 1?

For now, I will vote: 3lla and Ange and I will move to: the Shire.

[loser]

Has anyone played a game with a person sending list from beyond the grave? How did it work? How does one defeat them defeat them?

Stay: Rivendell

Vote: Ammer
for voting for me
Vote: Christopher
because I know you wanted to.

[Wind]

Hm, on a reread my previous post sounded rude XD; sorry Twiz, I didn't mean that I think your theory is impossible. Just that... well, it'd be an awesome twist, but I really hope it's not like that because I wouldn't know how to handle it.

[DM was on fire!]

Has anyone played a game with a person sending list from beyond the grave? How did it work? How does one defeat them defeat them?

Could it maybe be a zombie role?
Or perhaps a team whose spokesperson died?
*shrug*

Vote: Ammer (for voting for me)
Vote: ckillor (random)
Stay in: Isengarde (BECAUSE THE HOBBITS ARE HERE)

[Pickles]

Voting Update:
Christopher (2) - Bruces galore, loser
DM (1) - Ammer
loser (1) - Ammer
Wind (1) - Pink
3lla (1) - May
Ange (1) - May
Ammer (2) - loser, DM
ckillor (1) - DM

Locations:
the Shire: Bruces galore, May
Bree:
Rivendell: Pink, loser
Moria:
Lothlórien:
Isengard: DM
Fangorn Forest:
Minas Tirith:
Helm's Deep:
Mordor:

Execution is in 8 hours from the time of this post.

[Ammer]

I'll move to Mordor.

[machinedreams]

Move to: Isengard
Vote: loser1921

[Rachel]

Becore I forget Move: Lothlórien

And I am going to Vote: Hansy
because he said the following back on page 9:

Maybe Anvil's death is bad in the end, the innocent team would work harder if they felt in danger.

which just strikes me as a little strange that he would use the phrase "the innocent team" rather than "we all" or something like that, as if he is not part of the "the innocent team".

Hansy; feel free to defend yourself, but as no other leads have been posted on the thread so far, we need to try and find some or "the innocent team" are much less likely to win!

[loser]

Unvote:Christopher
Vote: Machinedreams

Do you just like voting for me?


And I guess that makes more sense than nothing...
Unvote: Ammer
Vote: Hansy

[Siniri]

Vote: Hansy
Move to Mordor
because Rachel's logic makes a bit of sense, and it's better than a no-vote. And Mordor because no one else is there yet...

[Rubywinged]

Move to: Isengard

Vote: no Execution (unless I decide to random that later lol)


-ponders the happenings-