Pink Poogle Toy Forum

...Governor? Sir/Madame?

I really do hope you know what you're doing. >_<

Oh well. At least the Mafia's backup was killed.

...Even if we did lose our Psychiatrist. -_-

Gah.

:/

Ok, where did you say in the thread that there would be axe murderers in this game? From what you posted I got the impression that you knew there would be an axe murderer all along, so I thought that it may have been your role.

Well, my guess is as good as any, at least it is not based on some randomiser like some people base their votes on.

I think in the feedback thread he posted something about an axe murderer role. I'm not sure though.

Does anyone have suspicions for execution though? I don't, but I don't want to do a random vote at the risk of losing an innocent

I didn't say anything about Axe murderers or any other kind of third bad guy team in this thread until after NPM was found stabbed with an axe. I think I mentioned it as a suggestion in the Feedback thread, but I might have said it in a chatroom. I know I suggested it, but I can't remember where for sure. In a way I was hoping there would be, but that was just because I wanted my suggestion used. This is worse than basing it on a randomizer, you're basing it on info you fabricated in your head, like a witch hunt.

Edit: I went back through the last Commentary and the Feedback threads, and I didn't mention it on the forums. I would've sworn I had it in here, but I only suggested it to Scott through AIM. I had no clue he used the role. But then again, it could be some kind of vigilante or something, but not many people use axes to kill. It all just clicked in my head when I saw that.

OK, then, I thought you said you mentioned the existence of such a role on the game thread, thus making me wonder how you could have gotten prior knowledge of it. However, I have other less orthodox reasons for voting you:

Neopetsmom was killed. IMO, why would anyone target her this early in the game, especially since she only posted once? It must be either

1) Someone who feels that she is too clever/experienced/whatever and may be a threat to them.

2) Someone who harbours a past grudge towards her.

In the last game, NPM posted her theories on the game thread, accusing you of being the Mafia. Her arguments caused you to confess on the game thread. Thus, the only candidate in my mind which fits both of the criteria listed above is you. I'm not saying that you killed her because you wanted revenge, rather, because you wanted to eliminate those who are a greater threat first.

Of course, I may be totally off-track, and all my ideas may be wrong, but this sure beats random voting anyday.

Okay. I know I'm probably really stupid for pointing this out, but Oka wasn't the only one she blamed or whatever. She also blamed me, for the reason that I didn't post half as much as I should have. However, I have no bad feelings towards her or anything. In fact, our time together in the Commentary thread just made me think she was really cool-a person to be idolised. Or something like that.

See? Stupid. Why did I just say that? I dunno. I guess I just want to defend Oka in this one aspect... that he wasn't the only one who could harbour a past grudge against Neopetsmom. And I am seriously not hinting if Oka is an Innocent or a baddie - I honestly don't know.


Eh, I'll shut up for now.

The difference is, she just mentioned you in passing, and didn't really write a full paragraph on why you are most likely to be the last-standing mafia. Furthermore, her suspicions about you were wrong, so obviously you wouldn't form a grudge towards her. If you remember, Okamoto was really quite angry with NPM on the game thread when she deduced his role.

But as I said, I voted for him because there is no one else suspicious as of yet, and it sure beats random voting. I may change my vote if more evidence and clues surface.

Eh? You totally confused me there... Heh. I was just saying that Oka may not be the only one who has a grudge on her... what is so complicated about that?

I guess the way I worded every thing was weird, though...

Urth: "Owww! That dog was definitely not cute and cuddly!"

Death: "YOU KNOW YOU'RE DEAD RIGHT?"

Urth: "Yah, I think the blood was a dead giveaway... pun intended."

Looks like I'm out of the game eh? See ya guys in round 4 I guess. (I was killed by a werewolf right?)

Hey Urth! You can't post here anymore! You can post int he commentary thread however! (don't reply to this post -.^)

As a reminder, the next execution IS TOMORROW.

Oh yeah, they're every day now. Which means we can't take as long to pick who looks suspicious, and to vote.

So... any ideas? *looks around*

It seems you didn't realize I had gotten over all that. Proof? I stated I wanted the dead to keep talking. Why would I have a grudge about NPM talking in the graveyard if I supported the continuation of it. I was far more angry at the innocents at the end.

Well...we got a criminal! YAAAAAAY!


But lost a psychoticdude.


I suppose you can't miss something you never knew about...

~http://www.princeton.edu/~mafia/vr7.htm

Maybe we have a vigilante? Only I think the vigilante works for the innocents....
Scott, you're mean!

Psychiatrist? You're right I suppose. Its too bad we lost him, but at least we got a Baddie, and we don't know exactly what the power was.. But I can't stop thinking about what those unintelligle words could have been--come to think of it, I can't stop thinking about a lot of things about this game, on both forums.

My ideas? None so far. If I get any, I'll be sure to let you know.

Oh! Looking down, I saw that Starchaser had posted. She could be right about the Vigilante thing, however, if you fill in the blanks (-------) you get Vigilan. Fill it in with Criminal, and you get Crimina. Fill it in with Moongazer, and you get Moongaz. So, either Scott didn't have the number of blanks to the exact number of letters, or, there is an entirely new role that we have never heard about filling in the blanks. I think those were what he was talking about, anyways... I'll do fill in the blanks a bit more before I go to bed...