Pink Poogle Toy Forum

Maybe the axe murderer person really wanted to hit someone else but that person was protected by the equivelent to the shamen/archangel for the axe murder. So the part about Ixistant not supposed to be there could mean that the axe murder really wanted to hit someone else, but couldn't because they were protected.

Of course I could also be completely wrong and we have some other weird random role like the psychitrist we didn't even know about and somehow they intervened and did something. Who knows?

But I agree with you, that part sounds like the blinded part that happened to Neopetsmom (sounds like it in terms of it sounds like something happened to intervene and Scott is giving us a clue we don't understand).

Well, if the person the stabber tried to kill had been protected, it would've been a "failed stabbing" and no stabbing would take place. Like last game, had I tried to shoot someone who was protected, there would've been a "failed shooting"

ARGH. I knew it, I knew we shouldn't have voted for Qanda Ah well. I don't have time to read through the pages, so I'll do a majority, and vote for:

Vote: Yesitish


EDIT: Is confused, ahhh, I understand, I put Yesh instead of yes. Changed ^^;

Now I remember the name of the role... It's called flip-flopper (you can check the rules and the commentary thread, Qanda mentioned it)
So the flip-flopper probably switched Ixistant and a person X, the axe murderer targeted X but killed Ixistant instead.

Flip-flopper, I just hope you know what you're doing. Ixistant was innocent, and if you protected the Angel/Mystic/etc it's very good, but if X was a baddie...

Me? I changed my vote at last minute because since there was no majority, I figured an excution is better than no excution.

But at that moment I had forgotten the governor would choose if there was no majority ._____. (Last game, if there was no majority, there would be no excution)

[Edit]


Actually, I remember from last game that werewolves/mafias sent a list of three people so if the top one was protected, the second one would be mauled/shot instead and so on.

I was thinking about that, and it's possible I was switched.

Switched for what?

Please tell me you were switched with Ixi, and not that your target was switched...

Switched with Ixistant, the serial killer/axe murderer could've easily targeted me last night. Did you guys try to target someone last game who was protected? We didn't, I just assumed that when it said there would be a "Failed shooting" that that would be it, and no death would occur from the Mafia.

Yeah I'm sure that what Oka means is if it was a switch it meant that Oka was meant to be killed by the axe not Ixistant.

No, I don't think anything like that happened to the werewolves last game. I'm not sure if when your top person is protected, you maul/shoot the second person but I assumed that was what the list of people was for instead of just giving one name to ScottNak.

Yeah, it was a joke... a bad one, ok? Forget about it...
I think that if a baddie sends in a list with 3 names, and the first one is protected, he doesn't kill the second one. He just "fails" the shot.
I must go now... *fingers crossed for execution, I really do hope YesItIsh isn't a helpful character*

But then, if that happens what would the other people on the list be for?

My thought about the three-person list was this: People aren't always able to be on after the execution to submit a list for the mauling/shot, so they submit a list of three people earlier in the day. Well, the first person on the list might be executed, (and from last game, you did know whether you were going to maul/shoot first because that was the way it was set up so you really would've only needed two last game) then a bad guy team might submit their list before you, and might kill the second person on your list. Well, in that case you would attempt to kill the third person on your list. Wait, there are three bad guy teams this time, so wouldn't you need to submit a list of 4 people?

I think the list it just in case the person on top is killed before the next kill comes along. Of course, it's a list of three, not two, so I may be wrong.

EDIT: Looks like he got it before me