Fri Dec 24, 2004 6:51 pm
I'm not going to be on today for very long but could someone PM the inactive people and ask them to add their vote? Dawn is looking very suspicious.
Fri Dec 24, 2004 7:15 pm
Soul Steal- 22 required
Dawn2- 12 vote: plducala16, Kugetsu, flatluigi, meowth1982, cap, YesItIsh, gundam_kola01, laq, o_0, warxelo, Matt, Wind,
Dawn2- 12 vote: plducala16, Kugetsu, flatluigi, meowth1982, cap, YesItIsh, gundam_kola01, laq, o_0, warxelo, Matt, Wind,
Fri Dec 24, 2004 7:47 pm
I can message some people, but I'm sure people are tired of me posting and urging. 
It IS Christmas Eve, so I doubt that such a great amount of people are going to be on.
To the living people - if you can get majority, please do. At this point in time, Dawn is a much bigger threat than DarkLegendary. It would be better to get rid of her first, since Dark is no longer active.
It IS Christmas Eve, so I doubt that such a great amount of people are going to be on.
To the living people - if you can get majority, please do. At this point in time, Dawn is a much bigger threat than DarkLegendary. It would be better to get rid of her first, since Dark is no longer active.
Fri Dec 24, 2004 8:04 pm
Ok.. Dawn.
How can innocents win if you are evil? They need to exterminate evil. If they don't do so, they lose.
Who cares what you SAY YOU ARE. The innocents CAN'T WIN AT ALL unless ALL EVIL IS GONE. Your role is EVIL.
You were the biggest killer the entire game. The innocents need you gone. For their good. So what if you say killing you off would be a mistake. Not killing you off is even worse.
My 2 cents.
How can innocents win if you are evil? They need to exterminate evil. If they don't do so, they lose.
Who cares what you SAY YOU ARE. The innocents CAN'T WIN AT ALL unless ALL EVIL IS GONE. Your role is EVIL.
You were the biggest killer the entire game. The innocents need you gone. For their good. So what if you say killing you off would be a mistake. Not killing you off is even worse.
My 2 cents.
Fri Dec 24, 2004 8:34 pm
plducala16 wrote:Ok.. Dawn.
How can innocents win if you are evil? They need to exterminate evil. If they don't do so, they lose.
Who cares what you SAY YOU ARE. The innocents CAN'T WIN AT ALL unless ALL EVIL IS GONE. Your role is EVIL.
You were the biggest killer the entire game. The innocents need you gone. For their good. So what if you say killing you off would be a mistake. Not killing you off is even worse.
My 2 cents.
Try and listen to reason. She protected people for many nights and many of those people she protected were innocents. She helped you guys kill off Werewolves. Isn't that enough? She was on the side of innocents. Sure, we can soul steal her tonight but if she protects an Innocent and the mafia member targets that innocent, they will die. Than perhaps you can kill her. Don't soul steal her now.
I am NOT going to soul steal Dawn.
Fri Dec 24, 2004 8:43 pm
Dawn, that's the point. To get you to reveal your coin colour. Obviously if you did reveal it to me, I was going to ask one of the townsfolk I was in contact with if that was against the rules or not. I didn't ask you just for the heck of it.
It shouldn't really matter if she is killed tonight because if we get a double execution and Stephanie isn't a baddie, the we win right there. I don't see why we should prolong the inevitable....
It shouldn't really matter if she is killed tonight because if we get a double execution and Stephanie isn't a baddie, the we win right there. I don't see why we should prolong the inevitable....
Fri Dec 24, 2004 8:46 pm
Kugetsu wrote:It shouldn't really matter if she is killed tonight because if we get a double execution and Stephanie isn't a baddie, the we win right there. I don't see why we should prolong the inevitable....
If we let Dawn die than that blows our chances of saving an innocent. She could protect someone and if a Mafia targets them, they'll die instead.
Fri Dec 24, 2004 8:49 pm
Ammer wrote:Kugetsu wrote:It shouldn't really matter if she is killed tonight because if we get a double execution and Stephanie isn't a baddie, the we win right there. I don't see why we should prolong the inevitable....
If we let Dawn die than that blows our chances of saving an innocent. She could protect someone and if a Mafia targets them, they'll die instead.
That's true, but if we kill of Dawn and Dark, there can only be one possible baddie left. Dark can only be the last mafia member (Stepanie was proven "not mafia" as far as I know), and Dawn is the "Jelly Poisoner". Even if Stephanie is bad, she can't attack anyone.
The only other possibility can be a conversion, which there is also an obvious choice for. No matter the situation, the game will end tonight or tomorrow, and the innocents win.
Twiz - I didn't say Stephanie was the last mafia member. I said Dark was
Fri Dec 24, 2004 9:42 pm
Ammer.. How do we know Dawn isn't lying? Not saying you are lying, but she could be yanking our leg. she could be a really, really evil person trying to confuse us.
And with your method of bribery Dawn.. if you are WHAT YOU SAY YOU ARE, I will buy you a codestone.
And with your method of bribery Dawn.. if you are WHAT YOU SAY YOU ARE, I will buy you a codestone.
Fri Dec 24, 2004 9:46 pm
Hehe, get that codestone ready. 
I don't see why Dawn would lie about something like this.
Now Dawn, look on the bright side. You can end the year with a bang.
I don't see why Dawn would lie about something like this.
Now Dawn, look on the bright side. You can end the year with a bang.
Fri Dec 24, 2004 9:50 pm
O_o; Ookay. I don't understand why Dawn would bother to reveal her role, and then go and yell at all of us because we don't believe her.
Hey, the game is based on lying, right? And there's no way to tell who's lying and who's not, right? Unless you have proof you'd like to share.. (Not accusing you here, Dawn, just pointing out that there's really no point in getting worked up over it)
I have four cents, not two. *throws four cents into the fountain*
Hey, the game is based on lying, right? And there's no way to tell who's lying and who's not, right? Unless you have proof you'd like to share..
(Not accusing you here, Dawn, just pointing out that there's really no point in getting worked up over it)
I have four cents, not two.
*throws four cents into the fountain*
Fri Dec 24, 2004 11:44 pm
plducala16 wrote:Ammer.. How do we know Dawn isn't lying? Not saying you are lying, but she could be yanking our leg. she could be a really, really evil person trying to confuse us.
We don't. We simply have to go on her claim.
Sat Dec 25, 2004 2:37 am
Well Ammer Dawn has already claimed to be evil and the Mafia is defeated. So despite our best efforts, good seems to have won this time.
Sat Dec 25, 2004 2:37 am
Maybe if she gives up cookies, we won't have to kill her. :3 I wonder if she can switch the execution every time? o_-