American Idol 5

[ahoteinrun]

Ace's performance was awful. Just... awful.
I'm watchign it right now. Just... awful.
Golly gosh... just... wow. SO BAD. I hope he's gone.

[WIS]

Today was actually pretty good day. I thought everyone with the exception of Ace and perhaps Bucky was okay. Kellie didn't do as bad as I thought she would.

I'm hoping Ace and Bucky will end up in bottom three. So my guess would be them and perhaps... Elliot?

[Bangel]

Maybe it's only me, but I actually thought the night went very well, considering for the most part, it should have been a disaster. Even Bucky and Ace sounded fine to me (I do agree that Ace didn't rock it enough, but really, he stopped the falsetto junk and actually tried something else, and that is awesome in any definition of the term). :P

Incase you didn't hear, he did do the damn falsetto junk at the end of the song. Ace, GO HOME ALREADY. You have sucked for the past (AT LEAST) five performances.

I was annoyed at Kellie because she didn't suck as horribly as I wanted her to. But what the hell was up with her eyes?! Like Simon said, it was like night of the living dead. I'm tired of her stupid act. "On paper?! lolz I don't have an accent!1!!1!!" GO AWAY, KTHNX.

By the way, Paris, nice outfit... if you're twenty five.

[Kugetsu]

A lot of people pull out falsetto at the end of their songs (if they're capable). It wasn't substantial enough to be worth the whine (or worth my notice).

Regardless, though, the only singer left that's not very good and has a chance of going home is Bucky, because we know everyone is going to flock to Ace and Kellie (Kellie would be a lot more tolerable if it wasn't for the stupid crap she pulls after her performances. Sorry, but no one is that dense, but still, she isn't the worse of the bunch right now.)

Also, after hearing Catherine's performance back on the radio (with no disturbances) it was actually ear-murdering at the beginning. I don't know why the judges thought it was one of the best performances.

[o_0]

Falsetto = Good.

Ace's Falsetto = Dying Mosquito.

[Amethyst]

I LOVE TAYLOR.


....Ahem. Anyway, I'm not going to be too critical, because they were doing Queen songs. Seriously, no one can go up with a Queen song and make it original.

Ace and Kellie should be long gone. In fact, Kellie doesn't deserve to live anymore after what she did to Bohemian Rhapsody. She can't sing, her stupid act is getting REALLY wearing, and she does NOT look good in leather >.>

[Kugetsu]

Falsetto = Good.

Ace's Falsetto = Dying Mosquito.

*thinks twice before squashing any more mosquitoes*

Some of Simon's critiques were a bit awkward. xD Like when he said "Strange" (or something near that) to Paris's performance and that's all, I wasn't sure if he was talking about the clothing, the performance, or just her trying to rock out. xD

[WIS]

By the way, Paris, nice outfit... if you're twenty five.

Oh my god, Amen to that. She looked like Paula trying to be young.

[Hil]

Ace's performance was awful. Just... awful.
I'm watchign it right now. Just... awful.
Golly gosh... just... wow. SO BAD. I hope he's gone.

Yes it was, but to be fair, We Will Rock You really isn't a 'singing' song. I mean, it's a GREAT song, but it doesn't really show off the vocals. It's more of a shouting song. But yeah, he was awful. I doubt he'll go though because of all the crazy fangirls.

I KNOW Kellie's not going anywhere, but her performance was awful. She looked like David Bowie or something.

Predictions for bottom 3 based on how AMERICA is voting (Don't agree with it ):
1. Paris (I think she'll be leaving)
2. Elliot
3. Bucky (His performance was better than Ace's last night, but he's not as popular as him)

Who I think SHOULD be in the bottom 3:
1. Ace (Want him to leave)
2. Bucky
3. Kellie

Chris and Taylor BETTER not be in the bottom three...or else. They did pretty good last night so hopefully they'll be safe.

[Bangel]

Why, oh why, America, is Ace still there after that monstrosity? *cries*

[-Ducky-]

ha ha, I just watched it a few minutes ago (recorded it onto a DVD last night) and I gotta say, Ace totally murdered that song.

I think that Pickle Lady did better then she usually does, but agree that she was really scary looking. I also agree that she is a dim-witted moron (heck, my goldfish is smarter) "what? paper? what do you mean? " I can't understand his accent." "what?, Me?, what accent?" god she drives me crazy. if Pickle lady wins, remind me to shoot myself.

that old looking guy with the grey hair did alright, but i'm not a big fan.

Chris I think did awesome. he was in his element. i've been a fan of him from the start and hope he makes it to the top.

bucky needs to go, like NOW. how does he NOT get kicked off. My goldfish can sing better then him, heck anyone with half a brain can sing better.

[WIS]

Heh, I was right. Yeah, he needed to leave. Perhaps Ace next week.

I dont get why everyone thought Paris was going to leave, I thought she did a pretty good job?

[Kugetsu]

Believe me, it's not because she didn't sing well, it's because those that didn't have fangirls/fanboys to back them up while the ones that actually did well get kicked in the butt. Ace should get the hatchet next week though, we know he's not going to win (along with Pickler), but it's a matter of when they're out. Bucky had to go sometime too, but Ace is the one doing most of the terrible performances right now. Bucky's were always considered "okay" but Ace's been terrible for the last couple of weeks. (like... 5 or 6 or every week but the first)

I think runners for the top three are Chris, Katherine, and Taylor/Kellie (that's how I see it playing out). I don't think Elliot and maybe even Paris don't have the backing they need to go to the top three (though I think at least one of them should).

I'd really prefer that Taylor/Kellie was Elliot/Paris

[DM was on fire!]

Poor Dino after Dark (B 93.7, local station) will never be right.
Even I thought Ace would leave -- and I didn't even get to watch it!

[ahoteinrun]

Wait wait wait... I missed the show; who got voted off?