American Idol 5

[Hil]

I'm just going to let the censors take care of my emotions.

WHAT THE smurf IS WRONG WITH AMERICA?! PICKLER CAN BE smurf SAFE BUT CHRIS IS IN THE smurf BOTTOM THREE?! WHAT THE HELL IS UP WITH THAT?! SCREW THAT UTTER, UNBELIEVABLE smurf.

It's because whenever Kellie says something stupid, she gets more votes than everyone else. At least thats what I think.

[____amanda]

I think the only reason Chris was in the bottom two was because some of his fans didn't like the softer side of him or something, which is completely ridiculous as he sounds amazing whatever he's singing. But I think Kellie should have been gone this week, even if it was a good thing Ace is bye-bye.

[NeoPet_online]

OMG thank Jeysus* for DVR! I miss TiVo, but whatever. I loved tonight's AI 5 theme, I mean what better than, The Greatest Love Songs?!

Katharine - Kat was AMAZING tonight, the judges were so hard! I think she did better than Elliot, but whatever. And yes, I do have the McPheever! She's in my top three.
Audio - 10, Visual - 10

Elliot - Elliot sang better than ever actually IMO. Only I thought it was for, not to. And yea I do tend to be a favoritist, but whatever, and Paula tearing up made me tear up too. He sang really good.
Audio - 11, Visual - 9

Kellie - I hate to love her, but I just do! I think she's genuinely that dumb, Ihave friends like that, so... I had no idea she could get that high, I mean I know it's not that high, but it's up there. I can sing whistle notes, but thats aside. She actually sang VERY well! I am very surprised, and I love Andrea to death! Lol had to get that in! AND WHAT IS WRONG WITH THE JUDGES?!?!?!?! Gahd! They're so hard on the girls!
Audio - 5, Visual - 5

Paris - Paris is flawless. Point blank. Like Andrea said, Spectacular. Amazing instrument. I can't believe she's only 17, she makes me feel like the worst singer in the world. She's just... GAHD!!! She'll be timeless, regardless of wether she wins or not. The judges were so hard on all of the girls. Poor Kat and Paris :'( And I love all of her hairs xD Top three.
Audio - 9, Visual - 7

Taylor - Same as with Kellie only I hate him, and I hate that I hate him, same as with Grease (The Movie), I never liked Grease, loved the songs, hated the movie, and all my friends don't believe me when I say I don't like it. Same with Taylor, if he were to win, I'd be enfuriated. I couldn't bear with an Idol who seizures everytime he sings. And it pains me to say this, I love ho he sang 'Just Once' it's one of my favorite songs. If it were only audio and no video I would be his fan, but no. And my dad LOVES him for some strange reason. And the judges take down their first male.
Audio 10, Visual 5 (He didn't move around too much this time so :S)

Chris - I loved how they did tht whole singing on the floor thing, I remember a video of Christina A. singing a song like that, I think it was the one about her father hitting her mom (I'm Okay?), but it really does help. He sang really good tonight, he's in my top three, just because Mandisa got the boot. I could imagine going to one of his concerts.
Audio - 10, Visual - 9

Overall a very good show. one of the best, I miss Big Band night *tear*, but yea very, very good. And House was awesome tonight.

*=My friends say that and it cracks me up!

(^^^One of my longest posts!^^^)

((666 is ^^^ CREEPY! Lol!))

Last edited by NeoPet_online on Wed Apr 26, 2006 2:26 am, edited 2 times in total.

[o_0]

I think she's genuinely that dumb

o_o votefortheworst.com > The Truth About Kellie

I really really hated Kellie and Taylor today, more than usual. I can't understand how Kellie has gotten so far. She's had 3 acceptable performances in 11 weeks!!!

[NeoPet_online]

I think she's genuinely that dumb

o_o votefortheworst.com > The Truth About Kellie

I really really hated Kellie and Taylor today, more than usual. I can't understand how Kellie has gotten so far. She's had 3 acceptable performances in 11 weeks!!!

Actually now I've wateched it for the... Nth time... Kellie was way off pitch, and the song wasn't good so yea, I'm going to edit it in a few if I can ... Taylor, eh I actually kind of liked him tonight... Just slightly. SLIGHTLY. The RW: KW was actually good tonight xD.

[Kitten Medli]

Well.. meh.. I kind of think it'll go like this:

Top:
Taylor
Katharine
Chris (!)

Bottom:
Kellie*
Elliot*
Paris

*bottom two

Leaving: Kellie

But, for some reason I can sorta see Kathrine go.. just.. for the "DUDE THATS WHACK" effect.

[NeoPet_online]

Well.. meh.. I kind of think it'll go like this:

Top:
Taylor
Katharine
Chris (!)

Bottom:
Kellie*
Elliot*
Paris

*bottom two

Leaving: Kellie

But, for some reason I can sorta see Kathrine go.. just.. for the "DUDE THATS WHACK" effect.

I would flatline if Kat left. And if Paris left. That's it for me, no more AI for me :'(

[WIS]

I really hope Kellie leaves, but I just cant really see that happening.

The top three, probably, is Katherine, Chris and Paris. Elliot was pretty good too. Unfortunatly, I can see the bottom three being:

Paris
Elliot
Katherine

[Kitten Medli]

Sometimes the better people go too soon. (IE, Jennifer Hudson)

[Bangel]

Bottom three prediction: Kellie, Paris, Elliott

[Kugetsu]

I'm going to have to put them in this order: (and quite easily, actually)

Chris (he was awesome, enough said)
Katherine (people need to get over the fact that just because you sing a song by a legend that you're not trying to show you're better than they are)
---
Elliot (I missed part of this one, but I can still say easily that it belongs here)
Paris (It was good, but it was also a bit... strange. I think sometimes she overdoes it and it just comes out the wrong way)
---
Taylor (Boring, boring, boring. It was just average, which we can't have at this stage of the competition. Sorry, not good enough.)
Kellie (Never have I so much felt the need to slam my head against the corner of my desk and shove sharp objects into my ears.)

(divided as top/middle/bottom as each section was amazingly in their own league [great/good/no good])

Bottom three should be Paris, Taylor, and Kellie, but I know that won't happen.

[NeoPet_online]

Well according to DialIdol, which I check religiously, The bottom three are *teartearteartear* Katharine, Kellie and Paris. I don't care anymore, you can't put that smurf in the same categorie as Kat and Paris. If she's safe I will scream. This is smurf. I love that xD. But yea, total smurf!

DialIdolRank|Idol
1-3|Taylor Hicks
1-3|Chris Daughtry
1-4|Elliott Yamin
3-5|(B3)Katharine McPhee
4-6|(B3)Kellie Pickler
5-6|(B3)Paris Bennett

[Kugetsu]

Somehow I don't even think Kellie's going to be in the bottom three (and I think DialIdol's way off this time). x_x

I'm going to guess the bottom three will be: Paris, Taylor, and Chris/Katherine (I'm sure someone that sings well will be down there).

Paris will probably be going home tonight. x_x

[NeoPet_online]

This is bullsmurf, Taylor and Elliot?!?! Safe?!?!? Whatever.

Gahdang. I am so happy Katharine is safe.

BYE BYE KELLIE!!!

Awww.... I'm kinda sad now...

[Bangel]

DING DONG, THE PICKLE'S DEAD.

AND CHRIS WAS IN THE HIGHEST NUMBER OF VOTES, RSOFJSFJSFJGSG.

:DDDDD