American Idol 5

[NeoPet_online]

I know this sounds incredibly biased, but that whole number switch up might not've been a mistake, I actually think that that shows she might actually win. Unfairly, but she might win. Either that or they'll do that to her. I definantly think Elliot is going home next week. I don't care what Paula says.

[Runevalkyrie]

Ok so some bad stuff might have happened in his life and sure he wanted to provide for his kids but I he should've been getting a real job instead of wasting his time trying to win a competition. There are plenty of jobs out there and just because he didn't win AI doesn't mean that his kids are going to starve to death or anything. It's not like he died. Why cry your eyes out over that but not every time you see a 'Christian Children's Fund' commercial? I'm sure the other contestants had valid reasons for wanting to win also. And I did watch the show, for the first few seasons. Then I found something better to watch. It really didn't matter to me who won the contest because they'd just be another face in Hollywood.

That's because YER SO MUCH BETTAR THUN EVRY1ELSE 4ND YER SUCH A M4N!!! OMG!!!111 Nah, I don't think so, far from it, in fact.

I'm not as nice as Bangel or Jas. Shut up and go away, troller (and you're not even very good at that).

I honestly hate butting into something, but this ends here.

Snippy - You are under no obligation to agree with the consensus and how they feel over it, however, it doesn't give you any right to say what you said in such a matter. People are drawn into it to the point that the contestants are a part of their lives and react accoringly.

Kugetsu - I think you've been around here long enough to know that was uncalled for as well. It would have been better if we handled him rather fanning the flames.

[Kugetsu]

Ok, as obvious as it is, I was out of line when I posted my last message, and I apologize to Snippy for being, ironically, snippy. While I don't like seeing other people being belittled or antagonized (It's a pet peeve), I realize, that fighting fire with even more fire was the incorrect way to handle it as, naturally, it just ended up spreading into an even larger and stronger flame. Obviously that was not an acceptable solution to this problem, and I acknowledge this. I won't deny that I wouldn't have replied with some sort of rude or snide remark, but it definitely would not have been to such a caliber as this was. I'd also like to apologize to Amethyst and Neopet_Online for a couple of pages back, I was harsh during those times too, and for no viable reason, as far as I can tell.

Also, I apologize to Yoshi for having to go out of his way to mod me, when he really shouldn't have been forced to, considering I should have been able to restrain myself and prevent this from even happening in the first place.

And another one to the viewers of this thread in general for causing this mess to begin with.

Anyway, in three seconds, I will snap my finger and you will wake up with no knowledge as to what has just happened. It never even existed. Seriously.

[and don't think this is just some tacked-on apology that I was forced to do. I've been planning on doing this all day (I had to leave, so I couldn't worry about it at the time). I did this of my own free will and I mean what I said. (as sincere or insincere as it ended up sounding,)]

Now... carry on as usual.

[NeoPet_online]

It's okay Kugetsu, we al lgot waaaaaaaay to caught up in this whole debate, and to tell you thruth it was loads of fun. But in the end we all havce to remember that it's just a show. Lol.

Oh and hey Rune haven't seen you in a while xD

[Amethyst]

Forgive and forget

I'm honestly not sure what's going to happen anymore. If Katherine does really bad this week, she might be the next one to go. On the other hand, I think Eliott could be next, simply because his fanbase isn't as large. I'm pretty sure Taylor is going to be in the finale; people like him too much for him not to be.

It's getting intense!

[NeoPet_online]

It kills me to say this.

But...

Taylor might actually win. I hate that idea, but I think he might. I know this is mean but I hope he does horrible this week. I really do. I seriously want Katharine to win.

[ahoteinrun]

If Taylor wins... then I think American Idol is in big trouble.

[Bangel]

If Taylor wins... then I think American Idol is in big trouble.

I think if any of them win, American Idol is in big trouble. The one person left they could possibly make money off is Katharine.

[o_0]

If Taylor wins... then I think American Idol is in big trouble.

I think if any of them win, American Idol is in big trouble. The one person left they could possibly make money off is Katharine.

Yep.

I hope Katharine wins and makes an adult contemporary album (not some pop one >.>).

[NeoPet_online]

All we, as viewers, can do is vote like crazy and hope for the best.

[Michelle]

I believe Katherine will be going home this week. Elliot and Taylor will be in the finale where Taylor will win it all.

[NeoPet_online]

Doing this one live!

First Round - Clive Davis Choice
Elliot - Open Arms - He did okay, I mean I seriously don't think he's gonna be top two.
Audio - 5, Visual - 7

Katharine - I Believe I Can Fly - KAtharine sang this really good. I loved it to death!
Audio - 8, Visual - 8.5

Taylor - Dancing in the Dark - It was okay. I sorta liked it.
Audio - 7, Visual - 8


Second Round - Judges Choice
Elliot - What You Won't Do For Love - This song bored me to death. No climax at all. Paula wants him.
Audio - 4, Visual - 5

Katharine - Somewhere Over the Rainbow - Okay, anymore bashes? This girl is awesome. She doesn't need to have seiszures onstage to sing good. If she doesn't win, which I think she will, she'll so do a musical.
Audio - 10, Visual - 10

Taylor - You Are So Beautiful - It was really good! I liked it! Very reminiscent.... Ahh.. .The good old days! PLEASE STOP DOING THAT SOUL PATROL THING!!!
Audio - 9, Visual - 8


Thrid Round - Contestant Choice
Elliot - I Believe to My Soul - He's trying too hard now, he's a goner, I'm sorry Yaminians.....
Audio - 6, Visual - 7

Katharine - I Ain't Got Nothin' But the Blues - I loved this song, she rocks at these songs!!
Audio- 8, Visual - 9

Taylor - Try a Little Tenderness - This song... Eh.. Ugh.. ZzZ.... Not for me. Donkey sang this better.
Audio - 7, Visual - 6

[Michelle]

<a><img src="http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y12/Tinkerbell_710700/10238702_l.jpg" border="0" alt="Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting"></a>





EDIT:
Ohmigawd. How can anyone STAND Katherine. I just listened to her "Somewhere Over The Rainbow" song. She sang it so weird. Like in the beginning I could hardley hear her and then all of a sudden she starts screeching and yelling like a mad woman. [ Okay okay it wasn't that dramatic but geez ] I can't see how anyone likes her.

[WIS]

I like Katherine. I do have to say, that Over the Rainbow preformance was excellent. At first I thought she was going to do what bo did, sing without any band/instruments. I glad a piano accompanied her.

Any other week is okay, but I'm going to be really mad if she gets booted off this week.

[NeoPet_online]

That picture of Taylor creeped the blue out of my smurf.

She sang it amazingly. There were no screeching or yelling sounds.

And I like her. Heck I LOVER HER. I don't think you should criticize the people who like her. I don't go around saying, wow sheesh, I can't see how anybody would like Taylor! So I think that was a bit harsh.