Pink Poogle Toy Forum

I think Haley's eliminating have been a long time comin', though. So it wasn't exactly a shocker.

I still stand that Haley shouldn't have gone home. She shouldn't have been in the bottom two so much, either. Most of the girls have a strong voice, hers might not be the strongest, but I believe it was stronger than Phil's (don't shoot me *comes out with hands up*). Phil's does wonderfully with the high notes, but when its time to get all mellow and soft, it sounds "kinda pitchy dawg"

Phil's just boring. :\ He's like the opposite of what Taylor Hicks was last year. He has a great voice (strongest male, actually), but his performances aren't entertaining, at all. I'll be the first to say that being entertaining is important, but not everything, obviously. I just think you need to have a mixture of both, and Phil definitely doesn't have that. :\ When it comes to someone who has a subpar voice, but is entertaining, and a person with a great voice, but boring, I'd take the former in a second.

And strangely, Sanjaya isn't necessarily entertaining, and usually doesn't show a great voice (even if he has it). He did well this week, but he'd better keep on doing that. I think it's just charm outside of the singing, which is a TERRIBLE thing to base a vote upon. -_-;

OK I just had to say this. This show is so over-rated. I'm so tired of it now, am I the only one????

It is over-rated, but this is the first season where I've watched most of it. Usually I tune in for the auditions and random rounds if anything.

But it is a popular show, so it's not going anywhere until after its contract is over.

For many of us it's a guilty pleasure. Just like watching all those kids shows you watch but deny afterwards.

I openly admit that I will wake up at 8:30 in the morning just so I can watch Arthur. I miss shows with good strong family values. And Arthur just makes me giddy.

Hey... it's a wonderful kinda day... where you can learn to laugh and play and get along with each other...

I'm very very very glad that Haley was voted off. Now I'm just waiting for Phil, Chris, and Sanjaya to go away...

Chris isn't that bad, but I wonder how long he'll survive though. He's been in the bottom three a few times.



I love Arthur. I always watch it with my sister.

XD
I'm guilty of that too.

I promised myself I wouldn't watch it this year...until I heard about Chris Sligh.
He got kicked off, so I don't care about it anymore. I haven't watched it since.

I AM SO HAPPY THAT HALEY IS GONE!
ok it doesnt meanthat i dont want phil t go but like yes i was so happy haley was gone......i do guiltyfully say thatsanjayas performance was really good
it hurts me to say that!
i still loved blakes performance! i think hes the best. Melinda didnt seemall that good doing sway, i also thought it was a little boring........

does anyone know the name of the song that blake sang???? i know its by marc anthony but whats it called????

XD
Every single person I talk to, and everyone on the radio, says that Sanjaya's last performance was good. I have to go see it for myself.

And...from the maker of the Sanjaya Anthem...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Te3X5-3cJL0

I don't know if I would say Sanjaya was good...Good is such a strong word...He was better than he usually is though.

true true....when i mean good i mean compared to sanjayas own standards though, not the same standards as blake or melinda because we all definetly know that he is n where near the same as them!

I think the song is called "I Need to Know"