Pink Poogle Toy Forum

Oh wow really? *is surprised*

Got a link? I'd really like to see it.

Naw, I don't remember what it is...

Did said wiki have a source?

Not to sound like an english teacher...

I don't believe the auditions, as far as I know, are scripted. I did a quick search on Vote for the Worst, and it didn't really come up with anything from the website, and if the auditions were scripted I believe VftW would be the first to report. I think some of the "confessionals" are scripted, or at least pushed in a certain direction (but they often show that on TV. You know, the part where the contestant goes "You want me to do ____ in front of the camera?")

Who do you guys like?

I like Brooke White and David Archuleta (the one who looks like 13). My favorite contestant is Carly Smithson though (the Irish girl).

I was hoping Josiah would get through.

I didn't like Josiah at all. I didn't think he sang that well, and I thought he was annoying.

Josiah annoyed the hell out of me.......english wannabe........

but there's that one blonde girl, the one who played the keyboard during hollywood week, who I quite like.
David Archuleta is ok, but I don't really see him going that far.......

Australian dude just confuses me though........sometimes he's good sometimes he isnt....I'll just have to see how he does.....

I haven't been watching lately. Hopefully I'll get caught up over vacation next week.

Ditto.

He was like "At least it took guts"; I was like, are you kidding me? It takes guts for EVERYONE auditioning. So happy Simon put him in his place.

He was so over-confident; thank GOD he is out

I like Brooke White. Although from certain angles she kind of reminds me of Sissy Spacek in Carrie. Really creepy. I feel like she'll snap any moment and wreck havoc on the entire audience with her telekinesis powers.

carly smithson annoys me..............."-_-

Well Josiah was never my favorite but he is better than say...Danny Noriega. That guy is the new Sanjaya.

I'm sort of getting bored with this show now. I like David, Michael, Carly, and Brooke but some of the other contestants are just so boring and generic (like Kristy and Kady). Also, I think Amanda should go - she would do much better as a lead singer in a band.

The last episode I watched was the second half of the guys, I think. Who was the first dude who was dancing like a crazed thing while singing? I liked him.
The guys with the guitar was... eh. Not so good.

I usually like tuning in to see who gets kicked off and I am happy with the choices. None of them really stood out for me.

Here's rooting for Jay Hernandez and David Archuleta!

i think that over the year the american idol contestants have just become more and more generic. Pretty much just clones of some other person.....it's actually incredibly boring now.....