The Dumbledore icon--I just find this more disturbing than funny. Yeah, yeah, I know, I'm weird. Don't dwell on it. XD
The next one is pretty good, I don't think you could improve it at all.
The Kakashi one is also good, unless you're actually SUPPOSED to be able to read the text without squinting up your eyes all funny-like and then slapping your forehead and proclaiming to your computer screen "Oh, FEELING blue!"
I like the Lucky*Star icon the most. Shiny and happy, and also barely legible again. (I'm sensing a theme here...)
I'm working on something in Illustrator at the time, and when I'm finished I'll post it for review.
Pre-warning: it's generic.
In the mean time, why not judge the set I made Helena (made in GIMP)?














