American Idol 6 [Split @ 11]

Message

WIS · #46 Post by **WIS** » Thu Apr 12, 2007 5:33 am

I think Haley's eliminating have been a long time comin', though. So it wasn't exactly a shocker.

____amanda · #47 Post by **____amanda** » Fri Apr 13, 2007 1:40 am

I still stand that Haley shouldn't have gone home. She shouldn't have been in the bottom two so much, either. Most of the girls have a strong voice, hers might not be the strongest, but I believe it was stronger than Phil's (don't shoot me *comes out with hands up*). Phil's does wonderfully with the high notes, but when its time to get all mellow and soft, it sounds "kinda pitchy dawg"

Kugetsu · #48 Post by **Kugetsu** » Fri Apr 13, 2007 2:43 am

Phil's just boring. :\ He's like the opposite of what Taylor Hicks was last year. He has a great voice (strongest male, actually), but his performances aren't entertaining, at all. I'll be the first to say that being entertaining is important, but not everything, obviously. I just think you need to have a mixture of both, and Phil definitely doesn't have that. :\ When it comes to someone who has a subpar voice, but is entertaining, and a person with a great voice, but boring, I'd take the former in a second.

And strangely, Sanjaya isn't necessarily entertaining, and usually doesn't show a great voice (even if he has it). He did well this week, but he'd better keep on doing that. I think it's just charm outside of the singing, which is a TERRIBLE thing to base a vote upon. -_-;

Doglefox · #49 Post by **Doglefox** » Fri Apr 13, 2007 5:12 am

OK I just had to say this. This show is so over-rated. I'm so tired of it now, am I the only one????

Ammer · #50 Post by **Ammer** » Fri Apr 13, 2007 5:20 am

Doglefox wrote:OK I just had to say this. This show is so over-rated. I'm so tired of it now, am I the only one????

It is over-rated, but this is the first season where I've watched most of it. Usually I tune in for the auditions and random rounds if anything.

But it is a popular show, so it's not going anywhere until after its contract is over.

WIS · #51 Post by **WIS** » Fri Apr 13, 2007 5:43 am

Doglefox wrote:OK I just had to say this. This show is so over-rated. I'm so tired of it now, am I the only one????

For many of us it's a guilty pleasure.

Just like watching all those kids shows you watch but deny afterwards.

ahoteinrun · #52 Post by **ahoteinrun** » Fri Apr 13, 2007 6:07 am

WIS wrote:
Doglefox wrote:OK I just had to say this. This show is so over-rated. I'm so tired of it now, am I the only one????

For many of us it's a guilty pleasure. Just like watching all those kids shows you watch but deny afterwards.

I openly admit that I will wake up at 8:30 in the morning just so I can watch Arthur. I miss shows with good strong family values. And Arthur just makes me giddy.

Hey... it's a wonderful kinda day... where you can learn to laugh and play and get along with each other...

Pink · #53 Post by **Pink** » Fri Apr 13, 2007 6:15 am

I'm very very very glad that Haley was voted off. Now I'm just waiting for Phil, Chris, and Sanjaya to go away...

WIS · #54 Post by **WIS** » Fri Apr 13, 2007 6:45 am

pinkflamingonewsgirl wrote:I'm very very very glad that Haley was voted off. Now I'm just waiting for Phil, Chris, and Sanjaya to go away...

Chris isn't that bad, but I wonder how long he'll survive though. He's been in the bottom three a few times.

openly admit that I will wake up at 8:30 in the morning just so I can watch Arthur. I miss shows with good strong family values. And Arthur just makes me giddy.

Hey... it's a wonderful kinda day... where you can learn to laugh and play and get along with each other...

I love Arthur. I always watch it with my sister.

DM was on fire! · #55 Post by **DM was on fire!** » Fri Apr 13, 2007 3:19 pm

ahoteinrun wrote:
WIS wrote:
Doglefox wrote:OK I just had to say this. This show is so over-rated. I'm so tired of it now, am I the only one????

For many of us it's a guilty pleasure. Just like watching all those kids shows you watch but deny afterwards.

I openly admit that I will wake up at 8:30 in the morning just so I can watch Arthur. I miss shows with good strong family values. And Arthur just makes me giddy.

Hey... it's a wonderful kinda day... where you can learn to laugh and play and get along with each other...

XD
I'm guilty of that too.

I promised myself I wouldn't watch it this year...until I heard about Chris Sligh.
He got kicked off, so I don't care about it anymore. I haven't watched it since. :roflol:

3lla · #56 Post by **3lla** » Fri Apr 13, 2007 7:29 pm

I AM SO HAPPY THAT HALEY IS GONE!
ok it doesnt meanthat i dont want phil t go but like yes i was so happy haley was gone......i do guiltyfully say thatsanjayas performance was really good :cry:

it hurts me to say that!
i still loved blakes performance! i think hes the best. Melinda didnt seemall that good doing sway, i also thought it was a little boring........

does anyone know the name of the song that blake sang???? i know its by marc anthony but whats it called????

DM was on fire! · #57 Post by **DM was on fire!** » Fri Apr 13, 2007 7:38 pm

XD
Every single person I talk to, and everyone on the radio, says that Sanjaya's last performance was good. I have to go see it for myself.

And...from the maker of the Sanjaya Anthem...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Te3X5-3cJL0

Pink · #58 Post by **Pink** » Fri Apr 13, 2007 8:28 pm

I don't know if I would say Sanjaya was good...Good is such a strong word...He was better than he usually is though.

3lla · #59 Post by **3lla** » Fri Apr 13, 2007 8:32 pm

pinkflamingonewsgirl wrote:I don't know if I would say Sanjaya was good...Good is such a strong word...He was better than he usually is though.

true true....when i mean good i mean compared to sanjayas own standards though, not the same standards as blake or melinda because we all definetly know that he is n where near the same as them!

____amanda · #60 Post by **____amanda** » Sat Apr 14, 2007 7:38 pm

ellamcumber wrote:does anyone know the name of the song that blake sang???? i know its by marc anthony but whats it called????

I think the song is called "I Need to Know"